| Name | Pos | B/T | Ht | Wt | DOB | Round | Pick # | Signed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jared Mitchell | CF | L / L | 6' 0" | 205 | 10/13/1988 | 1 | 23 | 07/08/2009 |
| Josh Phegley | C | R / R | 5' 10" | 220 | 02/12/1988 | CA | 38 | 06/25/2009 |
| Trayce Thompson | CF | R / R | 6' 3" | 215 | 03/15/1991 | 2 | 61 | 07/27/2009 |
| David Holmberg | P | R / L | 6' 3" | 225 | 07/19/1991 | 2 | 71 | 06/23/2009 |
| Bryan Morgado | P | L / L | 6' 3" | 205 | 12/08/1988 | 3 | 102 | Unsigned |
| Matt Heidenreich | P | L / R | 6' 5" | 185 | 01/17/1991 | 4 | 133 | 06/26/2009 |
| Kyle Bellamy | P | R / R | 6' 5" | 220 | 10/25/1987 | 5 | 163 | 06/21/2009 |
| Justin Collop | P | R / R | 6' 1" | 185 | 05/30/1988 | 6 | 193 | 06/23/2009 |
| Justin Jones | P | L / L | 6' 2" | 160 | 01/10/1991 | 7 | 223 | Unsigned |
| Ryan Buch | P | R / R | 6' 3" | 205 | 11/08/1987 | 8 | 253 | 06/23/2009 |
| Matthew Hopps | P | R / R | 6' 5" | 235 | 10/08/1985 | 9 | 283 | 06/23/2009 |
| Nick Ciolli | OF | L / R | 6' 2" | 215 | 12/06/1987 | 10 | 313 | 06/23/2009 |
| J.R. Ballinger | P | R / R | 6' 1" | 190 | 04/02/1988 | 11 | 343 | 06/26/2009 |
| Kyle Colligan | CF | R / R | 6' 2" | 210 | 04/23/1987 | 12 | 373 | 06/23/2009 |
| Cameron Bayne | P | R / R | 6' 2" | 195 | 02/14/1988 | 13 | 403 | 06/23/2009 |
| Dan Black | 1B | S / R | 6' 5" | 240 | 07/02/1987 | 14 | 433 | 06/21/2009 |
| Dane Williams | P | R / R | 6' 6" | 210 | 03/28/1991 | 15 | 463 | Unsigned |
| Daniel Wagner | 2B | L / R | 6' 0" | 185 | 07/12/1988 | 16 | 493 | 06/21/2009 |
| Brian Goodwin | CF | L / R | 6' 1" | 195 | 11/02/1990 | 17 | 523 | Unsigned |
| Phil Negus | P | R / R | 6' 2" | 205 | 11/10/1987 | 18 | 553 | 06/23/2009 |
| Brady Shoemaker | LF | R / R | 6' 0" | 200 | 05/10/1987 | 19 | 583 | 06/21/2009 |
| Nathan Reed | P | L / L | 6' 3" | 180 | 12/01/1987 | 20 | 613 | Unsigned |
| Jared McDonald | SS | L / R | 6' 1" | 180 | 03/01/1988 | 21 | 643 | 06/26/2009 |
| Zachary Kayne | SS | S / R | 5' 10" | 185 | 11/22/1986 | 22 | 673 | 06/23/2009 |
| Goldy Simmons | P | R / R | 6' 4" | 210 | 10/29/1988 | 23 | 703 | 06/21/2009 |
| Jeffrey Tezak | 2B | S / R | 5' 10" | 180 | 02/23/1986 | 24 | 733 | 06/23/2009 |
| Michael Strong | P | L / L | 6' 0" | 194 | 11/17/1988 | 25 | 763 | Unsigned |
| Matthew Harughty | 2B | R / R | 6' 0" | 180 | 07/28/1986 | 26 | 793 | 06/23/2009 |
| Kyle Davis | 2B | R / R | 5' 11" | 160 | 01/08/1987 | 27 | 823 | 06/21/2009 |
| Robert Cummings | 3B | R / R | 6' 2" | 195 | 08/14/1987 | 28 | 853 | Unsigned |
| Trey Delk | P | R / R | 6' 0" | 190 | 12/17/1985 | 29 | 883 | 06/23/2009 |
| Robert Vaughn | C | R / R | 5' 10" | 190 | 07/07/1987 | 30 | 913 | 06/21/2009 |
| Ryan Hamme | CF | L / R | 6' 3" | 210 | 03/13/1987 | 31 | 943 | 06/23/2009 |
| Jake Wilson | P | R / R | 6' 0" | 195 | 08/12/1987 | 32 | 973 | 06/23/2009 |
| Chase Cooney | P | R / R | 6' 8" | 245 | 12/18/1987 | 33 | 1003 | 06/23/2009 |
| Alex Farotto | P | L / L | 5' 11" | 195 | 03/28/1987 | 34 | 1033 | 06/23/2009 |
| Daniel Wiltz | P | R / R | 6' 1" | 200 | 02/13/1987 | 35 | 1063 | 06/21/2009 |
| Ryan Crowley | P | L / L | 6' 3" | 190 | 11/15/1990 | 36 | 1093 | Unsigned |
| Joseph Serafin | P | L / L | 5' 10" | 185 | 02/27/1986 | 37 | 1123 | 06/21/2009 |
| Anthony Casario | OF | L / R | 6' 1" | 175 | 02/21/1988 | 38 | 1153 | 06/21/2009 |
| Paul Burnside | P | R / R | 6' 4" | 225 | 11/20/1986 | 39 | 1183 | 06/23/2009 |
| Leighton Pangilinan | 1B | L / R | 6' 3" | 230 | 03/06/1991 | 40 | 1213 | 06/26/2009 |
| Ryan Lee | CF | R / R | 6' 0" | 185 | 02/11/1986 | 41 | 1243 | 06/21/2009 |
| Christopher Zagyi | P | R / R | 6' 5" | 215 | 08/05/1989 | 42 | 1273 | 06/21/2009 |
| Tyler Williams | 3B | L / R | 6' 2" | 200 | 01/05/1991 | 43 | 1303 | Unsigned |
| Taylor Thompson | P | R / R | 6' 5" | 225 | 06/18/1987 | 44 | 1333 | Unsigned |
| Harold Baines | LF | L / L | 5' 10" | 165 | 12/18/1987 | 45 | 1363 | 06/21/2009 |
| Grant Monroe | P | R / R | 6' 4" | 200 | 09/29/1988 | 46 | 1393 | Unsigned |
| Jordan Yallen | OF | R / R | 5' 10" | 160 | 10/15/1990 | 47 | 1423 | Unsigned |
| Matthew Little | P | L / L | 6' 2" | 180 | 10/17/1990 | 48 | 1453 | Unsigned |
| Theron Geith | P | L / L | 6' 5" | 175 | 06/27/1989 | 49 | 1483 | Unsigned |
| Kevin Chapman | P | L / L | 6' 3" | 218 | 02/19/1988 | 50 | 1513 | Unsigned |
